Mistake #1: Tipping on the Post-Tax Amount
The Problem:
You're paying extra on government taxes that have nothing to do with the server's work. On a £100 meal with 12% tax, tipping 20% post-tax means you tip £22.40 instead of £20—you just gave an extra £2.40 to... the government?
The Math:
WRONG WAY:
Bill: £100 → With 12% tax: £112 → 20% tip on £112 = £22.40
Total: £134.40
RIGHT WAY:
Bill: £100 → 20% tip on £100 = £20 → Add 12% tax: £112
Total: £132
You just saved £2.40. Over a year of eating out, that adds up.
✅ The Fix:
Look for the subtotal on your bill—the amount before tax. Calculate your tip from that number. Most restaurant bills clearly separate subtotal and tax.
Or just use our tip calculator—it shows you exactly what to tip on the pre-tax amount.
Mistake #2: Tipping on the Discounted Bill
The Problem:
Got a coupon or discount code? Great! But your server still did the same amount of work. Tipping on the reduced bill means they get penalized for your savings.
Real Example:
You order £80 worth of food. Server brings everything perfectly.
You use a "50% off" deal. Bill is now £40.
Bad move: Tip 20% of £40 = £8 tip
Right move: Tip 20% of £80 = £16 tip
The server still carried £80 worth of plates. They deserve £80 worth of tip.
✅ The Fix:
Calculate your tip on the original bill amount before any discounts, coupons, or promotional codes. Some bills show "original total" and "discounted total"—use the original.
Mistake #3: Not Checking for Automatic Gratuity
The Problem:
Many restaurants automatically add 18-20% gratuity for large groups (usually 6+ people) or special events. If you don't notice and add another tip on top, you've just tipped 35-40%. Ouch.
⚠️ Where It Happens:
- • Large group dinners (parties of 6+)
- • Restaurant week or special event menus
- • Private dining rooms
- • Some tourist-heavy areas (they assume you won't notice)
- • Room service at hotels (common hidden charge)
What to Look For:
Check your bill carefully for lines labeled:
- • "Gratuity"
- • "Service Charge"
- • "Automatic Gratuity"
- • "Included Service Fee"
- • "18% Service" (UK restaurants)
✅ The Fix:
Always read your bill line by line before tipping. If gratuity is already included:
- ✓ You're done! You can leave as-is.
- ✓ If service was exceptional, you can add extra (but it's not expected).
- ✓ If the tip line on the credit card receipt is blank, write "INCLUDED" so you don't forget.
Mistake #4: Not Adjusting for Service Quality
The Problem (Both Directions):
Some people auto-tip 20% no matter what. Others refuse to tip more than 15% even for amazing service. Both are mistakes.
When to Tip LESS (12-15%):
- • Server was consistently rude or dismissive
- • Forgot your order multiple times (and didn't apologize)
- • Disappeared for 30+ minutes when you needed something
- • Argued with you about order mistakes
Important: Talk to a manager if service was truly bad. Don't just silently under-tip.
When to Tip MORE (22-30%):
- • Server went way above and beyond expectations
- • Handled your complicated dietary restrictions perfectly
- • Restaurant was slammed but they kept cool
- • Made excellent recommendations that enhanced your meal
- • Dealt graciously with difficult guests at your table
- • It's a struggling local business (post-pandemic era)
Mistake #5: Currency Conversion Confusion
The Problem:
You're traveling abroad, see "€50" on the bill, and think "that's like £40, so I'll tip £8." But you forgot to convert your tip back to euros, or you calculated the percentage wrong after converting.
Common Scenarios:
❌ Wrong:
Bill: $75 USD. You're from UK. Think "that's like £60, so 20% = £12." Leave $12 tip.
You just tipped 16% in dollars, not 20%.
✅ Right:
Bill: $75 USD. Calculate 20% in USD = $15. Don't convert to your currency first.
Tip in the local currency, calculated on the local amount.
💡 Extra Complication: Foreign Tipping Customs
You also need to know local tipping norms:
- • US/Canada: 18-20% standard
- • UK: 10-12.5% (often included as service charge)
- • Europe: 5-10% or round up
- • Australia: 10% optional
- • Japan: Don't tip at all (considered rude)
Don't apply your home country's percentage to every destination. Research local customs.
✅ The Fix:
Use our tip calculator—it supports multiple currencies:
- ✓ USD, GBP, EUR, CAD, AUD, NZD all built-in
- ✓ Enter the bill in local currency
- ✓ Select local tipping percentage
- ✓ Get accurate tip in the correct currency
Bonus: Quick Tipping Tips
💳 Tip in Cash When Possible
Servers get cash immediately. Credit card tips come later and sometimes the restaurant takes a processing fee.
📱 Use a Calculator App
Don't do mental math after three glasses of wine. That's how mistakes happen.
✍️ Fill Out the Total Line
When paying by card, write the final total including tip. Prevents receipt tampering.
🤝 When in Doubt, Be Generous
Service workers have tough jobs. An extra pound or two won't break you, but makes their day.
📚 Keep Reading
Stop Making These Mistakes
Our tip calculator eliminates all five of these errors automatically. Pre-tax calculation, multi-currency support, and instant accuracy.
Calculate Tips Correctly →